Overview

Israel

Israel's overall score on the DataGovHub metric

Israel

General Performance


Country	Region	Income category	total	Strategic	Regulatory	Responsible	Structural	Participatory	International
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	89.17	100	80	100	80	75	100
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	84.17	75	100	50	80	100	100
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	84.17	75	80	75	100	100	75
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80.83	75	80	50	80	100	100
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	79.17	75	100	25	100	75	100
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	78.33	100	40	75	80	100	75
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	72.50	75	60	25	100	100	75
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	70.83	50	100	25	100	50	100
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	70.83	50	100	25	100	100	50
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	68.33	75	100	25	60	50	100
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	67.50	50	80	25	100	50	100
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		65.00	100	100	25	40	100	25
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	65.00	100	60	25	80	75	50
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	63.33	50	80	25	100	50	75
Canada	North America	High income	63.33	50	40	75	40	100	75
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	63.33	50	80		100	75	75
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	60.00	75	80	25	80	50	50
United States	North America	High income	57.50	75	40	25	80	50	75
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	53.33	50	60	50	60	50	50
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	53.33	75	40	25	80	75	25
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	53.33	75	80	25	40	75	25
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	48.33	25	80		60	50	75
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	48.33	50	60		80	50	50
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	45.00		40		80	75	75
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	40.83	50	60		60	50	25
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	40.00	25	60		80	50	25
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	40.00	25	60		80	25	50
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	36.67	25	60		60		75
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	36.67	50	60		60	25	25
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	35.83		60		80	50	25
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	34.17	50	20		60	25	50
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	33.33	75	20		80	25
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	32.50	25	60	25	60		25
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	32.50	25	80		40	25	25
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	30.00		60		20	25	75
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	30.00	25	20		60	50	25
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	30.00				80	75	25
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	30.00		40		40	50	50
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	30.00	50	20		60	25	25
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	30.00		20		60	75	25
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	29.17	50	60		40	25
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	27.50		60		80		25
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	26.67	25	20	25	40	50
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	24.17		60		60		25
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income	19.17	50			40	25
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	13.33		40		40
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income	11.67		20			50
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income	10.00		20		40
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	10.00		60
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income	7.50	25	20
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	7.50		20			25
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	3.33		20

Compare


Country	Region	Income category	total	Strategic	Regulatory	Responsible	Structural	Participatory	International
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	89.17	100	80	100	80	75	100
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	84.17	75	100	50	80	100	100
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	84.17	75	80	75	100	100	75
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80.83	75	80	50	80	100	100
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	79.17	75	100	25	100	75	100
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	78.33	100	40	75	80	100	75
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	72.50	75	60	25	100	100	75
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	70.83	50	100	25	100	50	100
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	70.83	50	100	25	100	100	50
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	68.33	75	100	25	60	50	100
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	67.50	50	80	25	100	50	100
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		65.00	100	100	25	40	100	25
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	65.00	100	60	25	80	75	50
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	63.33	50	80	25	100	50	75
Canada	North America	High income	63.33	50	40	75	40	100	75
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	63.33	50	80		100	75	75
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	60.00	75	80	25	80	50	50
United States	North America	High income	57.50	75	40	25	80	50	75
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	53.33	50	60	50	60	50	50
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	53.33	75	40	25	80	75	25
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	53.33	75	80	25	40	75	25
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	48.33	25	80		60	50	75
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	48.33	50	60		80	50	50
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	45.00		40		80	75	75
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	40.83	50	60		60	50	25
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	40.00	25	60		80	50	25
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	40.00	25	60		80	25	50
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	36.67	25	60		60		75
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	36.67	50	60		60	25	25
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	35.83		60		80	50	25
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	34.17	50	20		60	25	50
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	33.33	75	20		80	25
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	32.50	25	60	25	60		25
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	32.50	25	80		40	25	25
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	30.00		60		20	25	75
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	30.00	25	20		60	50	25
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	30.00				80	75	25
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	30.00		40		40	50	50
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	30.00	50	20		60	25	25
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	30.00		20		60	75	25
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	29.17	50	60		40	25
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	27.50		60		80		25
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	26.67	25	20	25	40	50
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	24.17		60		60		25
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income	19.17	50			40	25
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	13.33		40		40
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income	11.67		20			50
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income	10.00		20		40
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	10.00		60
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income	7.50	25	20
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	7.50		20			25
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	3.33		20

Region

Middle East &
North Africa

Income Category

High
Income

Strategic

Learn more

Israel

Strategic Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 1 Score	Data strategy	Public administration data strategy	National guidelines for private sector data sharing	AI strategy
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Australia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
New Zealand	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	50		1		1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50		1		1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia	1 -	100	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50		1		1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50		1		1
Canada	North America	1 - High income	50		1		1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1			1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
United States	North America	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	1 - High income	50		1		1
China	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	25				1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	50		1		1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	50			1	1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	3 - Lower middle income	25				1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	50		1		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	2 - Upper middle income
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	50		1		1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	25				1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	50		1		1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	50		1		1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income
India	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	25				1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	3 - Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	50		1		1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	3 - Lower middle income
Bangladesh	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	25				1
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income

Compare Strategic


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 1 Score	Data strategy	Public administration data strategy	National guidelines for private sector data sharing	AI strategy
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1		1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75	1	1		1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75		1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1		1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75	1	1		1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1		1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	50		1		1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1		1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1		1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		100	1	1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1		1
Canada	North America	High income	50		1		1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1			1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75		1	1	1
United States	North America	High income	75	1	1		1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	50		1		1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25				1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	50		1		1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	50			1	1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	25				1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	25				1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	25				1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	50		1		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	50		1		1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	75	1	1		1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25		1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	25				1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	25				1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	50		1		1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	50		1		1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	25				1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income	50		1		1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income	25				1
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Learn More About Strategic

Strategic sources


Country	Data Strategy	1a Data strategy source	Public administration data strategy	Public administration data strategy source	National guidelines for private sector data sharing	National guidelines for private sector data sharing source	AI Strategy	AI Strategy Source
Argentina
Australia	1	The Data Strategy 2021-2025	1	The Australia Public Service Big Data Strategy 2013 Australian Public Service Better Practice Guide for Big Dat (Archived 2015) Intergovernmental Agreement on Data Sharing			1	2018-2019 budget announced a four-year investment to support the development of AI in Australia Artificial Intelligence Roadmap 2019
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh							1	National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2019-2024
Bolivia
Brazil			1	Digital Government Strategy 2020-2022 Fostering digital uptake and use among people, firms, and in government			1	Artificial Intelligence Strategy
Canada			1	Data Strategy Framework for the Federal Public Service Digital Operations Strategic Plan: 2018-2022			1	Pan-Canadian Artificial Intelligence Strategy (2017)
Chile
China	1	Data Security Law of China 2021 2015: State Council, Action Plan for Promoting the Development of Big Data (促进大数据发展行动纲要) 2017: Xi Jinping’s report at the 19th Party Congress (mentions the goals of building a cyber Power, digital China, and intelligent society) 2016: State Council, National Informatization Plan In the “13th Five year” Period(“十三五”国家信息化规划) 2021, 14th Five Year Plan and 2035 Vision Plan (noting building national integrated big data centers, fostering the development of new industries such as AI, big data, cloud computing, blockchain and cyber security) 2021, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, New Data Center development Three Year Action Plan (新型数据中心发展三年行动计划)	1	China's Five-Cross Data Governance Methodology Data Security Law of China 2021 White Paper on Big data			1	A Next-Generation Artificial Intelligence Development Plan Three-Year Action Plan to Promote the Development of New-Generation Artificial Intelligence Industry (2017) AI Standardization White Paper (2018) 2015: State Council, Guiding Opinion on actively promoting the "Internet +" Initiative(国务院关于积极推进“互联网+”行动的指导意见) 2020, National Development and Reform Commission, Digitization transformation Partnership Action Initiative(数字化转型伙伴行动倡议) 2021, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, Industrial Network Innovation Development Action Plan (2021-2023) (工业互联网创新发展行动计划（2021-2023年) 2021, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, Big Data Industry Development Plan in the 14th Five Year Period(“十四五”大数据产业发展规划), under drafting as of August 30, 2021
Côte d’Ivoire
Estonia			1	Estonian Interoperability Framework. Digital Agenda 2020 Public Information Act 2001			1	National AI Strategy 2019-2021 Artificial Intelligence for Eston ia AI - Kratt Strategy 2020 (Primary)
Ethiopia
European Union	1	A European Strategy for Data 2020 Towards a Common European Data Space 2018	1	European Interoperability Framework 2017	1	Guidance on sharing private sector data in the European data economy 2018	1	Communication on Artificial Intelligence (2018) Coordinated Plan on Artificial Intelligence (2018)
Finland	1	A Finnish Model for the Secure and Effective Use of Data 2019	1	Information Management in Public Administration Act 2019			1	Artificial Intelligence 4.0 2020 and Age of Artificial Intelligence 2017
France	1	General Interoperability Framework 2016 (Primary Source) Etalab guides Data as infrastructure Circular on the public policy of data, algorithms and source codes for a public data policy	1	General Interoperability Framework 2016 (Primary Source) Etalab guides Data as infrastructure Circular on the public policy of data, algorithms and source codes for a public data policy			1	For a Meaningful Artificial Intelligence: Towards a French and European Strategy (2018)
Georgia
Germany	1	Data Strategy of the German Federal Government 2021	1	Data Strategy of the German Federal Government 2021(Implementation Strategy)			1	AI Strategy 2020
Hungary							1	Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2020-2030
India		Unlocking Value from Data and AI: The India Opportunity 2020					1	National AI Strategy (2018)
Indonesia			1	One-Data Policy 2019			1	AI National Strategy 2020-2045 and Primary Source
Iran
Ireland			1				1	AI - Here for Good 2020
Israel			1	The National Digital Program of the Government of Israel 2017			1	5 Year National AI Plan 2020
Japan	1	2021 Data Strategy データ戦略タスクフォース（第４回）議事次第	1	Base Registry Roadmap	1	Contract Guidance on the Utilization of AI and Data 2018	1	Artificial Intelligence Technology Strategy (2017) AI Strategy 2019-AI for all people, industries, regions, and governments (Japanese only)
Jordan							1	Jordan Artificial Intelligence Policy 2020
Kenya							1	The Distributed Ledgers Technology and Artificial Intelligence Taskforce 2018
Malaysia
Mexico							1	Towards an AI Strategy in Mexico: Harnessing the AI Revolution (2018) Artificial Intelligence in Mexico: A National Agenda 2020
Morocco
Netherlands			1	NL Digitaal Data Agenda Government 2019	1	Dutch Vision on Data Sharing between Businesses 2019	1	Strategic Action Plan for Artificial Intelligence 2019
New Zealand	1	Data Strategy and Roadmap 2018	1	Data Strategy and Roadmap for New Zealand 2018	1	A Path to Social Licence Guidelines for Trusted Data Use	1	Artificial Intelligence 2018
Nigeria
Norway			1	One Digital Public Sector: Digital Strategy for the Public Sector 2019-2025 https://data.norge.no/guide/veileder-orden-i-eget-hus/	1	National Strategy for Artifical Intelligence 2020 - Section on private sector data sharing guidelines	1	National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2020
Pakistan
Philippines					1	Data Sharing Agreements 2020	1	National Artificial Intelligence Roadmap 2021
Russia			1	National Data Management System Uniform Requirements for the Governance of State Data			1	National Strategy for the Development of Artificial Intelligence 2019
Saudi Arabia	1	National Strategy for Data & AI 2020	1	National Data Governance Interim Regulations Data Management and Personal Data Protection Standards			1	National Strategy for Data & AI 2020
Singapore			1	Bringing Data into the Heart of Digital Government 2017 Public Sector (Governance) Act 2018	1	Singapore GUIDE TO DATA SHARING	1	National Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2019
South Africa
South Korea	1	Korea Digital New Deal	1	Korea Digital New Deal Public data management guidelines revision notice			1	Five-Year Plan to Strengthen the Country’s Research & Development in AI (2018) Mid- to Long-Term Master Plan in Preparation for the Intelligent Information Society Managing the Fourth Industrial Revolution National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2019 Announcement
Sweden			1	Final Report: Assignment to increase the public administration's ability to make open data available, pursue open and data-driven innovation and use artificial intelligence			1	National approach to artificial intelligence 2018
Switzerland	1	Digital Switzerland Strategy Objective 7: Data, digital content and artificial intelligence					1	Artificial Intelligence 2018
Taiwan			1	Digital Government Program 2.0 of Taiwan 2021-2025			1	Taiwan AI Action Plan
Thailand			1	Thailand 4.0 Plan 2015 Data Governance Framework
Turkey							1	National Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2021-2025
Uganda
Ukraine							1	Concept for the Development of AI 2020
United Arab Emirates			1	UAE Strategy for Government Services 2023 The UAE Digital Government Strategy 2025 UAE Smart Data Principles and Standards 2019			1	UAE Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2017
United Kingdom	1	UK National Data Strategy (2020)	1	UK National Data Strategy 2020	1	UK Data sharing: a code of practice	1	AI Sector Deal (2018) AI in the UK: ready, willing, and able? (2018)
United States	1	The Federal Big Data Research and Development Strategic Plan (2016)	1	U.S. Data Federation Project 2019 Federal Data Strategy 2020 Action Plan			1	Preparing for the Future of Artificial Intelligence (2016) National Artificial Intelligence Research and Development Strategic Plan (2016) Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and the Economy (2016) American AI Initiative (2019) The National Artificial Intelligence Research and Development Strategic Plan: 2019 Update
Uruguay			1	Paving Path for Data Drive Administration in Uruguay DATOS 360 2019 Data Policy for Digital Transformation			1	Artificial Intelligence Strategy for Digital Government 2019
Vietnam			1	Digital Government and Open Data Readiness Assessment 2019 Decree on the Management, Connection, and Share of Digital Data of State Agencies			1	National strategy on research, development and application of artificial intelligence

Regulatory

Learn more

Israel

Regulatory Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 2 Score	Law for the protection of personal data	Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default	Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents	Right to be protected from automated decision-making	Right to data portability
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Australia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1	1		1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	40	1		1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	60	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia	1 -	100	1	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	60	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
Canada	North America	1 - High income	40		1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
United States	North America	1 - High income	40		1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	1 - High income	60	1		1	1
China	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	80		1	1	1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	40	1				1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1		1	1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	60	1	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	40	1		1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	60	1		1		1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	3 - Lower middle income	60	1		1	1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	2 - Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	20			1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	60	1		1		1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	80	1		1	1	1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	20			1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	40	1		1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	60	1	1	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
India	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	3 - Lower middle income	60	1		1	1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	40	1		1
Pakistan	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income	60	1		1	1
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Bangladesh	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	20			1
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income	20			1
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	20			1

Compare Regulatory


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 2 Score	Law for the protection of personal data	Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default	Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents	Right to be protected from automated decision-making	Right to data portability
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	80	1	1	1		1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	40	1		1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	60	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		100	1	1	1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	60	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
Canada	North America	High income	40		1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
United States	North America	High income	40		1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	60	1		1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	40	1				1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	80		1	1	1	1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1		1	1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	60	1	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	40	1		1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	60	1		1		1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	60	1		1	1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	60	1		1	1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	20			1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	20	1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	60	1		1		1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	80	1		1	1	1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	60	1	1	1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	20			1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	40	1		1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	20			1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	20			1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	60	1	1	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	20			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	60	1		1	1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	40	1		1
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income	20			1
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income	20			1
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	60	1		1	1
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income	20			1
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	20			1
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	20			1

Learn More About Regulatory

Regulatory sources


Country	2a Law for the protection of personal data	2a Law for the protection of personal data source	2b Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default	2b Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default source	2c Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents	2c Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents source	2d Right to be protected from automated decision-making	2d Right to be protected from automated decision-making source	2e Right to data portability	2e Right to data portability source
Argentina	1	Data Protection Law No. 25,326: Executive Order No. 1,558/2001			1	Access to Public Information Law No. 27,275: Executive Order No. 206/2017
Australia	1	Privacy Act 1988 Privacy Principles	1	Public Data Policy 2015 Government Information Act 2009	1	Freedom of Information Act 1982			1	What is the Consumer Data Right?
Azerbaijan	1	Law of Azerbaijan Republic “on data, data processing and data protection”			1	Law on the Right to Obtain Information
Bangladesh					1	Right to Information Act 2009
Bolivia					1	Executive Order No. 28,168 on Public Transparency
Brazil	1	Brazilian Constitution (unofficial translation) Brazilian General Data Protection Law No. 13,709 (unofficial translation)	1	Decree Establishing Open Data Policy 2016	1	Law 12.527, Right to Information Law	1	Brazilian General Data Protection Law No. 13,709 (unofficial translation)	1	LGPD
Canada			1	Directive on Open Government 2014	1	Access to Information Act
Chile	1	Law No. 19.628	1	Law on Access to Public Information 2008	1	Law on Access to Public Information 2008
China			1	Open Government Information Regulations of the P.R.C. (2019) open by default	1	Open Government Information Regulations of the P.R.C. (2019)	1	Information Security Technology: Personal Information Security Specification 2020	1	New Personal Information Protection Law Chapter 6
Côte d’Ivoire	1	Law N. 2013-450 Côte d'Ivoire on the protection of personal data			1	Access to Information Law
Estonia	1	Personal Data Protection Act			1	Public Information Act 2001	1	PDPA § 21. Automatic processing	1	GDPR
Ethiopia					1	Freedom of the Mass Media and Access to Information Proclamation
European Union	1	The General Data Protection Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2016/679)	1	Directive on Open Data and the Re-Use of Public Sector Information 2019	1	Article 15 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union	1	Art. 22 GDPR: Automated individual decision-making, including profiling	1	Right to Data Portability GDPR and Co nvention 108 Article
Finland	1	The Data Protection Act (1050/2018)	1	Act on the Publicity of Activities of Authorities 1999 Act on Information Management in Public Administration	1	Act on the Publicity of Activities of Authorities 1999	1	GDPR	1	GDPR
France	1	Law 78-17 (The Data Protection Act, DPA) Decree 2019-536 (The Implementing Decree) Law 2016-321 (Law for a Digital Republic)	1	French Law for a Digital Republic 2016	1	Law on Free Access to Administrative Documents 1978	1	DPA Article 47	1	DPA Article 55 confirms the applicability of Art 20 Law for a Digital Republic, Title II, Chapter 1, Section 2 enhances these rights
Georgia	1	Law of Georgia on Personal Data Protection	1	The General Administrative Code of Georgia Decree of the Government of Georgia 219, About the Form of the Electronic Request of Information and Proactive Disclosure of Public Information“	1	The General Administrative Code of Georgia
Germany	1	Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG)	1	eGovernment Act 2013 amended with the Open Data Act 2017 Second Open Data Act (2021) - open by default	1	Federal Freedom of Information Act	1	BDSG Section 37	1	GDPR
Hungary	1	Act CXII of 2011 on the Right of Informational Self-Determination and on Freedom of Information			1	Freedom of Information Act 2011 LXIII of 2012 law on the recycling of public data	1	Act CXII of 2011 on the Right of Informational Self-Determination and on Freedom of Information	1	Act CXII of 2011
India					1	Right to Information Act
Indonesia					1	Act on Public Information Openness 2008
Iran					1	Law on Dissemination of and Free Access to Information
Ireland	1	Data Protection Act 2018	1	European Union (Open Data and Re-use of Public Sector Information) Regulations 2021	1	Freedom of Information Act 2014	1	DPA Article 57	1	GDPR
Israel	1	Protection of Privacy Law, 5741-1981	1	Government Resolution Nr. 1993 of 2016	1	Freedom of Information Law, 5758-1998
Japan	1	Act on the Protection of Personal Information (The amended Act fully put into effect on April 1, 2022)	1	Basic Law for Promotion of Utilization of Public-Private Data (Law No. 103 of 2016)	1	Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs
Jordan					1	Law on Guarantee of Access to Information Overview
Kenya	1	Data Protection Act No. 24 of 2019			1	Access to Information Law 2016	1	Data Protection Act No. 24 of 2019	1	Data Protection Act No. 24 of 2019
Malaysia
Mexico	1	General Data Protection Law for the Public Sector	1	Decree establishing the regulation on Open Data	1	Freedom of Information Overview Federal Transparency and Access to Information Law (Spanish)
Morocco	1	Law No. 09-08 - Processing of Personal Data Decree No. 2-09-165 - DP Law			1	Right to Information Law 2018 Carnegie Endowment News Article	1	Art. 11 of the Law on the Protection of Individuals with regards to the Processing of Personal Data (Overview)(Law in French)
Netherlands	1	GDPR Implementation Act			1	Government Information Act	1	GDPR Implementation Act Article 40	1	GDPR
New Zealand	1	Privacy Act 2020 (2020 No 31)			1	Official Information Act
Nigeria					1	Freedom of Information Act 2011
Norway	1	Personal Data Act			1	Freedom of Information Act 2009	1	Personal Data Act	1	Personal Data Act
Pakistan					1
Philippines	1	Republic Act 10173 – Data Privacy Act of 2012			1	Executive Order No. 2 on Freedom of Information 2016			1	Republic Act 10173 – Data Privacy Act of 2012
Russia	1	Federal Law on Personal Data 2006			1	https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-42855-6_22	1	Federal Law on Personal Data 2006
Saudi Arabia	1	https://ncar.gov.sa/Documents/Details?Id=waEbJasbk9cJVNdJ%2B31GUA%3D%3D
Singapore	1	Public Sector (Governance) Act 2018 Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA)							1	Amendment Act
South Africa	1	Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013			1	Promotion of Access to Information Act 2000	1	Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013
South Korea	1	Personal Information Protection Act	1	Act on the Promotion of the Provision and Use of Public Data 2013	1	Official Information Disclosure Act
Sweden	1	Data Protection Act			1	Freedom of the Press Act	1	GDPR	1	GDPR
Switzerland	1	Federal Act on Data Protection (Latest Amendments in 2019) Revised 2020 FADP (revFADP) implements more aspects of GDPR			1	Federal Act on Freedom of Information in the Federal Administration 2004	1	revFADP	1	revFADP
Taiwan	1	Personal Data Protection Act	1	Freedom of Government Information Law 2005 The Advanced Action Plan for Open Government Data	1	Freedom of Government Information Law 2005
Thailand	1	Personal Data Protection Act, B.E. 2562 (2019) https://www.dataguidance.com/notes/thailand-data-protection-overview			1	Official Information Act 1997			1	Personal Data Protection Act
Turkey	1	The Law on the Protection of Personal Data No. 6698			1	TURKISH LAW ON THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION Law No: 4982	1	The Law on the Protection of Personal Data No. 6698
Uganda	1	The Data Protection and Privacy Act of 2019			1	Access to information Act (ATIA) 2005	1	The Data Protection and Privacy Act of 2019
Ukraine	1	Law No. 2297-VI of 1 June 2010 on Protection of Personal Data			1	The Law on Public Access to Information	1	Law of Ukraine on Protection of Personal Data 2011
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom	1	Data Protection Act 2018 The Data Protection, Privacy and Electronic Communications (Amendments etc) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020			1	Freedom of Information Act 2000	1	Data Protection Act of 2018	1
United States			1	Foundations for Evidence-Based Policymaking Act 2017	1	Freedom of Information Act
Uruguay	1	Ley Dd Proteccion De Datos Personales Ley N° 18331			1	Right of Access to Public Information	1	Article 16
Vietnam					1	Law on Access to Information 2016

Responsible

Learn more

Israel

Responsible Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 3 Score	Digital charter	Public sector data ethics framework	AI ethics framework	Trust framework for digital identity management
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1	1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25		1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	25	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25		1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		25			1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25	1
Canada	North America	High income	75	1		1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
United States	North America	High income	25		1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	50	1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25			1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25			1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	25			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Compare Responsible


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 3 Score	Digital charter	Public sector data ethics framework	AI ethics framework	Trust framework for digital identity management
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1	1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25		1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	25	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25		1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		25			1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25	1
Canada	North America	High income	75	1		1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	25			1
United States	North America	High income	25		1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	50	1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25			1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25			1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25			1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	25			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Learn More About Responsible

Responsible sources


Country	3a Digital charter	3a Digital charter source	3b Public sector data ethics framework	3b Public sector data ethics framework source	3c AI ethics framework	3c AI ethics framework source	3d Trust framework for digital identity management	3d Trust framework for digital identity management source
Argentina
Australia			1	Public Sector Data Management	1	Australia’s Artificial Intelligence Ethics Framework	1	Trusted Digital Identity Framework Release
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh
Bolivia
Brazil	1	Civil Rights Framework for the Internet
Canada	1	Canada Digital Charter			1	Canada's Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence https://www.ipc.on.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/2021-06-04-ipc-comments-on-ai-framework.pdf	1	Pan-Canadian Trust Framework Overview
Chile
China					1	Governance Principles' for 'Responsible AI' Trustworthy AI White Paper 2019
Côte d’Ivoire
Estonia	1	Everyone's rights in the e-state
Ethiopia
European Union					1	ETHICS GUIDELINES FOR TRUSTWORTHY AI European ethical Charter on the use of Artificial Intelligence in judicial systems and their environment REPORT with recommendations to the Commission on a framework of ethical aspects of artificial intelligence, robotics and related technologies
Finland					1	Work in the age of artificial intelligence Publications of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment Ministry • 21/2018 Four perspectives on the economy, employment, skills and ethics Ethical information policy in the era of artificial intelligence
France					1	How can humans keep the upper hand? Report on the ethical matters raised by algorithms and artificial intelligence
Georgia
Germany			1	Opinion of the Data Ethics Commission	1	ETHICS COMMISSION AUTOMATED AND CONNECTED DRIVING REPORT (EXTRACT)
Hungary
India					1	Approach Document for India Part 1 – Principles for Responsible AI
Indonesia
Iran
Ireland			1	Data Sharing and Governance Act 2019
Israel
Japan					1	Social Principles of Human-Centric AI
Jordan
Kenya
Malaysia
Mexico
Morocco
Netherlands			1	Safeguards against the risks of data analyzes by the government Integrated government response to the reports «Upgrading – Safeguarding public values in the digital society » and «Human Rights in the Robot Age» of the Rathenau Institute Report on Ethics and Digitization	1	Handbook on non-discrimination by design Opportunities and risks of AI for the protection of fundamental rights
New Zealand			1	Algorithm charter for Aotearoa New Zealand Treaty of Waitangi/Te Tiriti and Māori Ethics Guidelines for: AI, Algorithms, Data and IOT	1	Trustworthy AI in Aotearoa AI Principles	1	Progressing Digital Identity: Establishing a Trust Framework
Nigeria
Norway					1	The National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 5 Trustworthy AI (establishes that Norway will use the EU High-Level Expert Group on AI's ethical framework) Artificial intelligence and privacy
Pakistan
Philippines
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Singapore					1	DISCUSSION PAPER ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI) AND PERSONAL DATA – FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE DEVELOPMENT AND ADOPTION OF AI Principles to Promote Fairness, Ethics, Accountability and Transparency (FEAT) in the Use of Artificial Intelligence and Data Analytics in Singapore’s Financial Sector MODEL ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE GOVERNANCE FRAMEWORK
South Africa
South Korea					1	Principles for a user-centered intelligent information society Human-Centered AI Ethics Standards
Sweden			1	New Technology Testing for Automation within Public Administration
Switzerland
Taiwan
Thailand					1	Digital Thailand AI Ethics Principles and Guidelines
Turkey
Uganda
Ukraine
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom	1	UK Digital Charter	1	Data Ethics Framework A guide to using artificial intelligence in the public sector	1	Artificial Intelligence: How to get it right	1	The UK digital identity and attributes trust framework
United States			1	Data Ethics Framework DOD Adopts Ethical Principles of Artificial Intelligence Principles of Artificial Intelligence Ethics for the Intelligence Community
Uruguay	1	Rights of digital citizenship	1	Artificial Intelligence Strategy for Digital Government
Vietnam

Structural

Learn more

Israel

Structural Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 4 Score	Data protection body	Open data portal	Open data body	Public sector data governance body	International data affairs body
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1	1	1		1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1	1		1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	80	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	60	1	1		1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		40	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	80	1	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Canada	North America	High income	40	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	80	1	1	1	1
United States	North America	High income	80	1	1		1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	60	1	1		1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	80	1	1		1	1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	40	1				1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	60	1	1		1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	80	1	1	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	60	1	1	1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	80	1		1	1	1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	80	1	1	1		1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	60	1	1		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	80	1	1	1		1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	60		1	1	1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	80		1	1	1	1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	60		1		1	1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	40	1	1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	20		1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	60		1	1	1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	40	1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	60		1		1	1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	60	1	1			1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	40		1	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	40		1			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	60	1	1	1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income	40		1			1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	40	1	1
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income	40			1	1
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Compare Structural


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 4 Score	Data protection body	Open data portal	Open data body	Public sector data governance body	International data affairs body
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1	1		1
Australia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1		1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia	1 -	60	1	1			1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	60	1	1		1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	80	1	1	1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Canada	North America	1 - High income	40	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	80	1	1	1	1
United States	North America	1 - High income	80	1	1		1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	1 - High income	60	1	1		1
China	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	40	1				1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	80	1	1		1	1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	60	1	1		1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	80	1	1	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	60	1	1	1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	3 - Lower middle income	80	1	1	1		1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	80	1		1	1	1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	60	1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	60	1	1		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	2 - Upper middle income	80	1	1	1		1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	60		1	1	1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	60		1		1	1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	40	1	1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	80		1	1	1	1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	20		1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	60		1	1	1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	40	1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	60		1		1	1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	40		1	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	80	1	1	1	1
India	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	40		1			1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	60	1	1			1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	3 - Lower middle income	60	1	1	1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	40		1			1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	40	1	1
Pakistan	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	3 - Lower middle income	40			1	1
Bangladesh	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income

Learn More About Structural

Structural sources


Country	4a Data protection body	4a Data protection body source	4b Open data portal	4b Open data portal source	4c Open data body	4c Open data body source	4d Public sector data governance body	4d Public sector data governance body source	4e International data affairs body	4e International data affairs body source
Argentina	1	Agency for Access to Public Information	1	https://datos.gob.ar	1	Ministry of Public Innovation and Undersecretariat of Open Government and Digital Country	1	Ministry of Public Innovation and Undersecretariat of Open Government and Digital Country
Australia	1	Office of the Australian Information Commissioner	1	http://data.gov.au/	1	Data and Digital Ministers' Meeting Office of the National Data Commissioner	1	Data and Digital Ministers' Meeting Office of the National Data Commissioner	1	Ambassador for Cyber Affairs and Critical Technology
Azerbaijan	1	Ministry of Communications and Information Technologies	1	https://www.opendata.az/en
Bangladesh
Bolivia					1	Electronic Government and Information and Communication Technologies Agency (AGETIC)	1	Electronic Government and Information and Communication Technologies Agency (AGETIC)
Brazil	1	Agência Nacional de Proteção de Dados	1	http://dados.gov.br/	1	Management Committee of the National Open Data Infrastructure (INDA)	1	Central Data Governance Committee Digital Government Secretariat - Ministry of Economy	1	Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Canada	1	Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada	1	http://open.canada.ca/en
Chile			1	http://datos.gob.cl/ https://www.portaltransparencia.cl/PortalPdT
China	1	China's key enforcement agencies							1	Bureau of International Cooperation
Côte d’Ivoire	1	Autorité de régulation des télécommunications/TIC de Cote d’Ivoire (ARTCI)	1	https://data.gouv.ci/
Estonia	1	Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate	1	https://avaandmed.eesti.ee/	1	State Information Systems Information System Authority or Information Society Council	1	State Information Systems Information System Authority or Information Society Council	1	Ambassadors-at-Large for Cyber Diplomacy and for Digital Affairs
Ethiopia
European Union	1	European Data Protection Board	1	http://open-data.europa.eu/	0		0		0
Finland	1	Office of the Data Protection Ombudsman	1	https://www.avoindata.fi/en			1	Public Administration Information Utilization Division of the Public Administration Information Management Board - Ministry of Finance
France	1	Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés	1	http://data.gouv.fr/	1	Etalab coordinates the policy of openness and sharing of public data ( open data ) : It coordinates the actions of State administrations and provides them with support to facilitate the dissemination and reuse of their public information	1	Chief Technology Officer & Chief Data Officer	1	Ambassador for International Affairs
Georgia	1	State Inspector's Service	1	https://www.data.gov.ge/	1	Data Exchange Agency	1	Data Exchange Agency
Germany	1	Die Bundesbeauftragte für den Datenschutz und die Informationsfreiheit	1	https://www.govdata.de/	1	Open Data competence center acts as a contact and support center for authorities.			1	Special Representative for Cyber Foreign Policy and Cyber Security
Hungary	1	Data Protection Commissioner of Hungary	1	https://kozadat.hu/kereso/			1	Data Assets Agency
India			1	http://data.gov.in/					1	International Cooperation Division, Ministry of Electronics and Technology
Indonesia			1	https://data.go.id/	1	Central Level Secretariat, and Steering Committee, of One Data Indonesia	1	Central Level Secretariat, and Steering Committee, of One Data Indonesia
Iran
Ireland	1	data protection commissioner	1	https://data.gov.ie/	1	Open Data Governance Board (ODGB) under the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, as set up by the Open Data Strategy	1	Data Governance Unit in the Office of Government Chief Information Officer (OGCIO); Data Governance Board	1	EU Affairs, Digital and Access to Finance Division
Israel	1	Israel Privacy Protection Authority	1	https://info.data.gov.il/datagov/home/	1	Government ICT Authority	1	Government ICT Authority
Japan	1	Personal Information Protection Commission	1	https://www.data.go.jp/?lang=english	1	Japan IT General Strategy Office The Information and Communication Technology (IT) Comprehensive Strategy Office of the Cabinet Office has set up a consultation desk to receive comprehensive questions and requests regarding the utilization of public-private data, including "Questions / opinions regarding requests for disclosure of government-owned data as open data and efforts by the government for open data"	1	Digital Agency
Jordan			1	https://portal.jordan.gov.jo/wps/portal/OpenData?lang=en	1	Ministry of Planning and International Cooperation, Open Government Unit Ministry of Digital Economy and Entrepenuership also plays a role	1	Ministry of Digital Economy and Entrepreneurship
Kenya	1	Office of the Data Protection Commissioner	1	http://opendata.go.ke/
Malaysia	1	Personal Data Protection Department (PDPD)	1	https://www.data.gov.my/	1	MAMPU Digital Government office	1	MAMPU Digital Government office
Mexico	1	Instituto Nacional de Transparencia, Acceso a la Información y Protección de Datos Personales	1	http://datos.gob.mx/	1	General Head Office of Open Government and Transparency of the National Institute for Transparency, Access to Information and Personal Data Protection (INAI)
Morocco	1	National Control Commission for the Protection of Personal Data	1	http://data.gov.ma/	1	Open Data Steering Committee of the Digital Development Agency
Netherlands	1	Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens	1	https://data.overheid.nl/			1	National program for Sustainable Digital Information Management	1	Policy, International, Strategy and Communication Department
New Zealand	1	Office of the Privacy Commissioner	1	http://www.data.govt.nz/	1	Chief Data Steward	1	Chief Data Steward Digital Government Partnership
Nigeria	1	National Information Technology Development Agency	1	http://www.data.gov.ng/					1	International Cooperation Operational Department, Ministry of Communication and Digital Economy
Norway	1	Norwegian Data Protection Authority	1	https://data.norge.no/	1	Directorate for Digitalisation (DIGDIR), formerly Directorate for Public Administration and ICT/Agency for Public Management and eGovernment, under the Ministry of Local Government and Modernisation	1	Norwegian Resource Center for Sharing of Data - DIGDIR
Pakistan
Philippines	1	National Privacy Commission	1	http://data.gov.ph/	1	Open Data Task Force Open data Philippines project is operated and maintained by the Technical and Data Management teams of the National Government Portal (NGP) project of the Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT). The policy direction of ODPH, as well as the coordination with the whole Philippine Government, is a joint effort of the members of the Open Data Task Force.	0
Russia	1	Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media (Roskomnadzor) Commission for the protection of personal data	1	http://opengovdata.ru/			1	National Data Management System (NMSS) Commission on Digital Development, the Use of Information Technologies to Improve the Quality of Life and Conditions for Doing Business Analytical Center
Saudi Arabia			1	https://data.gov.sa/en	1	Open data and Information Access Officer (ODIAO) within the National Data Management Office	1	National Data Management Office Saudi Data and AI Authority	1	International Partnerships Department of the Saudi e-Government Program
Singapore	1	Personal Data Protection Commission	1	http://data.gov.sg/			1	Government Data Office	1	International Partnerships
South Africa	1	The Information Regulator	1	https://southafrica.opendataforafrica.org/ https://www.datafirst.uct.ac.za/dataportal/index.php/catalog	1	Department of Public Service and Administration	0		1	Program 6: ICT International Affairs and Trade, Ministry of Telecommunications and Post
South Korea	1	Personal Information Protection Commission	1	http://www.data.go.kr/	1	Public Data Strategy Council : Open Data Strategy Council is an organization that deliberate, coordinate, monitor and evaluate government’s major Open Data policies, plans and their implementation. Public data refers to all databases, electronic files etc. that government and public sector organizations have electronically created or acquired and are managing	1	4th (Industrial Revolution) Committee, Data Special Committee Korean Data Industry Promotion Agency	1	International Cooperation Bureau
Sweden	1	Swedish Authority for Privacy Protection	1	https://www.dataportal.se/en	1	DIGG works to promote the making available and re-use of data from the public administration	1	DIGG	1	Office of International Affairs
Switzerland	1	Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner	1	https://opendata.swiss/en	1	Open Government Data office based at the Federal Statistical Office (FSO)	1	National Data Management NaDB Program through Federal Statistics Office- incharge of once only principle but that's it? Digital Transformation and ICT Management (DTI) in charge of master data management system	1	International Relations Division
Taiwan			1	https://data.gov.tw/en	1	Open data Action Plan 2021-2024 gives commitment 1-1, 'A complete system for opening and reusing government data,' to the Information Management Office of the National Development Commission, Division of Information Promotion Consultant Committee for Government Open Data
Thailand			1	https://data.go.th/			1	The Digital Government Development Agency "under the name "data.go.th" at the Digital Government Development Agency. (Public Organization) or NEDA was developed under the concept of being the center of access to open government information of the country that allows people to access government information conveniently, quickly, all the time".	1	Foreign Affairs Division
Turkey	1	Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu			1	Digital Transformation Office: Establishing and running the national Open Data Portal for sharing public data and determining the procedures, principles and standards on data transfer by public institutions to the Portal.	1	Department of Big data and Artificial Intelligence Applications	1	Department of International Relations, Presidents office of Digital Transformation
Uganda
Ukraine	1	Department for Personal Data Protection of the Secretariat of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Commissioner for Human Rights	1	http://data.gov.ua/	1	Ministry of Digital Transformation One of the priorities of the Ministry of Digital Transformation is the development of open data in Ukraine - we are working on improving the legislation, opening new data sets, and implementing various projects together with partners			1	Directorate General for Digitalization
United Arab Emirates			1	https://bayanat.ae/					1	Department of International Relations, Telecommunications and Digital Government Regulatory Authority
United Kingdom	1	The Information Commissioner’s Office	1	http://data.gov.uk/	1	Department of Digital, Culture, Media, and Sports (DCMS)	1	Data Advisory Board DCMS
United States	1	Federal Trade Commission	1	https://www.data.gov/			1	CDO Council	1	Digital Trade Attaches
Uruguay	1	Unidad Reguladora de Control de Datos Personales	1	https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/			1	Data Management Division
Vietnam			1	https://data.gov.vn/	0		1	The Ministry of Information and Communications	1	Department of International Cooperation

Participatory

Learn more

Israel

ParticipTORY Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 5 Score	Public consultation on personal data protection	Public consultation on public data	Expert advisory body on ethics	Expert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1	1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		100	1	1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75	1	1		1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
Canada	North America	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1		1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
United States	North America	High income	50	1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	50		1		1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75	1	1	1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	75	1	1	1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50	1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	50	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	50	1			1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	50	1		1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	25		1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	25		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	50	1	1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	25		1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income	25	1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	25	1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	25				1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	50	1	1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	50		1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	25	1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	75	1	1		1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
India	South Asia	Lower middle income	50	1	1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income	25		1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income	50	1	1
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income	25	1
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Compare Participatory


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 5 Score	Public consultation on personal data protection	Public consultation on public data	Expert advisory body on ethics	Expert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Australia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1	1
New Zealand	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	100	1	1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia	1 -	100	1	1	1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
Canada	North America	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
United States	North America	1 - High income	50	1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	1 - High income	50		1		1
China	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	75	1	1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	75	1	1	1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50	1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	50	1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	50	1			1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	3 - Lower middle income	25		1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	50	1		1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	2 - Upper middle income	50	1	1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	25	1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	25	1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	50	1	1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	75	1	1		1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	50		1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	25	1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	25	1
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income
India	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	50	1	1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	50	1	1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	3 - Lower middle income
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	25		1
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income	50	1	1
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	3 - Lower middle income
Bangladesh	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income	25	1
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income

Learn More About Participatory

International

Learn more

Israel

International Performance


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 6 Score	Convention 108+	Open Government Partnership	OECD AI Principles	Trade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Australia	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	High income	75		1	1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	50		1	1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	High income	100	1	1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia		25				1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	High income	50			1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1	1		1
Canada	North America	High income	75		1	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1		1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	High income	50		1	1
United States	North America	High income	75		1	1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	50	1	1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	High income	25				1
China	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25				1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	High income	75	1		1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	High income	50		1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	75	1	1	1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	25		1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	25			1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	Lower middle income	50		1	1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	Upper middle income	75		1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	25	1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	Upper middle income	25		1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	50		1		1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25				1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	25		1
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	High income	75		1	1	1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	Upper middle income	25		1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	Upper middle income	25				1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	50		1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	Lower middle income	25				1
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	Lower middle income	25		1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	High income
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income	25		1
India	South Asia	Lower middle income
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income	25		1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	Lower middle income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Bangladesh	South Asia	Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	Lower middle income

Compare International


Country	Region	Income category	Attribute 6 Score	Convention 108+	Open Government Partnership	OECD AI Principles	Trade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows
United Kingdom	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Germany	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Australia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
Netherlands	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
France	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
New Zealand	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
South Korea	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
Brazil	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	50		1	1
Ireland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
European Union	Europe & Central Asia	1 -	25				1
Finland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Sweden	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	100	1	1	1	1
Japan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	50			1	1
Estonia	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1	1		1
Canada	North America	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
Switzerland	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1		1	1
Norway	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	50		1	1
United States	North America	1 - High income	75		1	1	1
Uruguay	Latin America & Caribbean	1 - High income	50	1	1
China	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Singapore	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income	25				1
Hungary	Europe & Central Asia	1 - High income	75	1		1	1
Israel	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income	50		1	1
Argentina	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	75	1	1	1
Philippines	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	25		1
Ukraine	Europe & Central Asia	3 - Lower middle income	50		1	1
Turkey	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	25			1
Mexico	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	75		1	1	1
Russia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	25	1
South Africa	Sub-Saharan Africa	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
Indonesia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	50		1		1
Thailand	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Kenya	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	25		1
Saudi Arabia	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income
Chile	Latin America & Caribbean	2 - Upper middle income	75		1	1	1
Jordan	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
Malaysia	East Asia & Pacific	2 - Upper middle income	25				1
Côte d’Ivoire	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	50		1	1
Vietnam	East Asia & Pacific	3 - Lower middle income	25				1
Taiwan	East Asia & Pacific	1 - High income
Georgia	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income	25		1
India	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Nigeria	Sub-Saharan Africa	3 - Lower middle income	25		1
Morocco	Middle East & North Africa	3 - Lower middle income	25		1
United Arab Emirates	Middle East & North Africa	1 - High income
Azerbaijan	Europe & Central Asia	2 - Upper middle income
Pakistan	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Uganda	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Bolivia	Latin America & Caribbean	3 - Lower middle income
Bangladesh	South Asia	3 - Lower middle income
Ethiopia	Sub-Saharan Africa	4 - Low income
Iran	Middle East & North Africa	2 - Upper middle income

Learn More About International

International sources


Country	Convention 108	Convention 108 source	Open Government Partnership	Open Government Partnership source	OECD AI Principles	OECD AI Principles source	Trade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows	Trade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows source
Argentina	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Argentina Open Government Partnership	1
Australia			1	Australia Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://rcepsec.org/2020/11/26/rcep-a-new-trade-agreement-that-will-shape-global-economics-and-politics/
Azerbaijan	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108
Bangladesh
Bolivia
Brazil			1	Brazil Open Government Partnership	1
Canada			1	Canada Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://www.international.gc.ca/trade-commerce/trade-agreements-accords-commerciaux/agr-acc/index.aspx?lang=eng
Chile			1	Chile Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://www.subrei.gob.cl/landings/depa
China							1	http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Côte d’Ivoire			1	Côte d'Ivoire Open Government Partnership	1
Estonia	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Estonia Open Government Partnership			1	http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Ethiopia
European Union							1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Finland	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Finland Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
France	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	France Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Georgia	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Georgia Open Government Partnership
Germany	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Germany Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Hungary	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108			1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
India
Indonesia			1	Indonesia Open Government Partnership			1
Iran
Ireland	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Ireland Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Israel			1	Israell Open Government Partnership	1
Japan					1		1	http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Jordan			1	Jordan Open Government Partnership
Kenya			1	Kenya Open Government Partnership
Malaysia							1	https://rcepsec.org/
Mexico	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Mexico Open Government Partnership	1		1	http://www.sice.oas.org/ctyindex/MEX/MEXagreements_e.asp
Morocco	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Morocco Open Government Partnership
Netherlands	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Netherlands Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
New Zealand			1	New Zealand Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/trade/free-trade-agreements/free-trade-agreements-in-force/digital-economy-partnership-agreement-depa/
Nigeria			1	Nigeria Open Government Partnership
Norway			1	Norway Open Government Partnership	1
Pakistan
Philippines			1	Philippines Open Government Partnership
Russia	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108
Saudi Arabia
Singapore							1	https://www.mti.gov.sg/Improving-Trade/Digital-Economy-Agreements
South Africa			1	South Africa Open Government Partnership
South Korea			1	Republic of Korea Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://rcepsec.org/
Sweden	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Sweden Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Switzerland	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108			1		1	https://www.mofa.go.jp/region/europe/switzerland/epa0902/agreement.pdf
Taiwan
Thailand							1	https://home.kpmg/th/en/home/insights/2021/01/regional-comprehensive-economic-partnership-rcep.html
Turkey	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108			1
Uganda
Ukraine	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Ukraine Open Government Partnership	1
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	United Kingdom Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/the-uks-trade-agreements#trade-negotiations-the-uk-is-prioritising
United States			1	United States Open Government Partnership	1		1	https://ustr.gov/trade-agreements/free-trade-agreements
Uruguay	1	Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108	1	Uruguay Open Government Partnership
Vietnam							1	http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx